Beltran enjoyed great success while in New York. Despite his injury troubles in recent years, the six-time All-Star will go down as one of the best outfielders in Mets history. Beltran's best season as a Met was 2006, in which he hit 41 HR and 116 RBI at a .275 clip. Unfortunately, the lasting memory that season for most fans is Beltran's strikeout in the bottom of the ninth inning of game 7 of the NLCS.
Although he experienced a resurgence this year, Beltran's career in the Big Apple had run its course. When Sandy Alderson became the Mets general manager last Fall, he knew that he faced a gargantuan task. For unlike other cities, New York fans don't understand the word "rebuild". So although the Mets were going to lose major contributors through trade this year, it was imperative that Alderson kept this team in position to at least be competitive.
Alderson knew that players such as Francisco Rodriguez and Beltran had to be dealt; so did all of the Mets' potential trading partners. That's exactly why it would be very difficult to acquire value in exchange for New York's departing stars. Rodriguez was dealt for two low-level prospects. But that doesn't mean that the deal was a failure. In ridding themselves of K-Rod, the Mets avoided a $17.5 million option that was set to vest next season in the event that the closer finished 55 games.
The Beltran deal was even more of a success. Beltran played All-Star caliber baseball this season: 15 HR, 66 RBI, .289 BA. He's also surprised many by playing 98 games - good for second on his team thus far. With teams such as the Phillies, Red Sox, Giants, and Rangers looking for a quality outfield bat, Beltran was a highly valued commodity. In fact, he was arguably the most sought after position player in this year's trade market. With these conditions, it should have been easy for Alderson to receive top-level talent in exchange for the 34-year-old outfielder, right? Wrong.
In trading for Beltran, the San Francisco Giants are only getting a two-month rental. In addition, the fact that he is non-arbitration eligible made trading Beltran even more difficult - any team that traded for the three-time Gold Glove Award winner would not receive draft pick compensation when he hit free agency at the end of the season.
But Alderson did well, very well. In exchange for the two-time Silver Slugger Award Winner, the Mets received the Giants best pitching prospect. Righty Zack Wheeler has a mid-to-high 90s fastball and above-average off speed stuff. Although he has struggled with his control at times, Wheeler projects as a solid no.2 starter.
Throughout trade negotiations, Alderson was thought to have much too high of an asking price. In fact, before the Mets agreed to deal Beltran to San Francisco yesterday, many believed that Alderson would only be able to get mid-level prospects in a trade. That is why this trade is such a success: Alderson acquired the Giants' best young arm, a player who figures to be a big part of the Mets' future.
Landing Wheeler was a success for the Mets, and that should be celebrated. However, I would have liked to see Beltran continue to play for a team that is starting to get healthy. If they were at full strength all season, who knows what the Mets could have done this year.